Lost Key...

[Bassman]

Is there any way to get the last Silver key if you never marry Lady Grey? If this has been asked before, let me know.

[Vegeta]

Another way is if u have TLC you can do the side quest of the mystery "Lady Greys sister" and become mayor... u will be able to go in then still...

[Bassman]

Isn't that the one with the crazy guy and the lamp at the stable? did that, didn't give her the letter. Now I have finished the game and I can't open the last chest.

You have to fight Thunder to get to the cave where the key is, and to do that, you have to marry Lady Grey. Is there another way into the cave? or, is there another key that I don't know about?

[Vegeta]

you should be able to go back to Bowerstone North and become the mayor... and be aloud in the building...

[Hexadecimal]

Originally Posted by Bassman

Isn't that the one with the crazy guy and the lamp at the stable? did that, didn't give her the letter. Now I have finished the game and I can't open the last chest.

You have to fight Thunder to get to the cave where the key is, and to do that, you have to marry Lady Grey. Is there another way into the cave? or, is there another key that I don't know about?

... I think I know the key you mean... the one at Headsmans Hill, right?
well... you don't have to marry her I don't think, but you do have to be courting her, so that Thunder will fight you... his jealous streak is his only redeeming quality, really... and even then he's whiny about it...
however, if you found the letter and wouldn't give it to Lady Grey,she skips town so there's no reason for Thunder to fight you or kick your *** down the hill giving you access to the key... at least I don't think... I could be wrong... stranger things have happened...
... so looks to me like your only recourse is to play the game over again... I'm sure you'll suffer through somehow...

[Albion Knight]

Oh I remember now it's in the pond outside the cave. Same thing happened to me first time I played TLC. I think Hex is right. There is no other way to get that key legally meaning without a mod like Freeroam

Silver Key #23

Location: Headsman's Hill

Notes: You cannot obtain this key until later in the game when you battle Thunder for Lady Grey's hand in marriage. During the fight, Thunder will knock you off the cliff to a small area with a pond. Do some more fishing and you'll have yourself another key.

[droded]

Yeah I was going to say freeroam, but Todd beat me to it

[Albion Knight]

I don't think he has it on the pc though

[Angel]

I guess you could always try one of those exploit things if you really don't want to replay the whole game just for one key - but they are risky and may not work...

[Bassman]

oh well. i shall start a new new game, and i shall get that damn key.

[Vegeta]

lol...

I hate it when that happens...

[Dark Drakan]

Originally Posted by Bassman

oh well. i shall start a new new game, and i shall get that damn key.

Well heres a link to the list for future reference should you need it:

Fable 2 - Silver Keys

[Bassman]

Thanks. If I see Thunder in Bowerstone, I'm gonna get a jumpstart on beating his A$$.

[Tsuyu]

So the bottom line is: You "have" to fight Thunder during the Lady Gray-questline in order to get all 30 keys. If you choose to expose Lady Gray from the start you will not be able to get all 30 keys. However, after you've kicked Thunder's humungous behind, you can expose her if you wish.

[Albion Knight]

Originally Posted by Tsuyu

So the bottom line is: You have to fight Thunder during the Lady Gray-questline in order to get all 30 keys. If you choose to expose Lady Gray from the start you will not be able to get all 30 keys. However, after you've kicked Thunder's humungous behind, you can expose her if you wish.

You could also do the hero save thing on the Escort The Traders Quest